The iOS 10 beta on iPad adds some nice UI refinements in Nearby search.
The first two steps of a Nearby search are exactly the same in iOS 9. iOS 10 improvements start in the next step of the search, cafe in this case.
Instead of a mass of red drop pins the new iOS 10 Nearby UI offers search result icons with the cafe name in bold. If there is more than one cafe in the immediate area, Nearby displays a number. Tapping on the number icon filters the result list. The UI is dynamic and changes as you zoom in. The experience is cleaner and easier to use than Nearby search in iOS 9.
Another very nice addition, similar to Google’s approach, is the “Search Here” button that dynamically appears when you navigate to a adjacent area. Tap on it and Nearby searches again in the new area.
Justin O’Beirne has published part two of his epic essay comparing Google Maps and Apple Maps: “Content — The Map as a Whole”. It’s a great read and deep analysis.
I think there is a much simpler and subjective comparison test: is the map easy to read, does it convey the most important information at a glance? What is the map ‘Glance Quotient’?
Here are three comparison iPhone 6S screen shot views of Shinjuku Station (left to right) in Apple Maps, Google Maps and Yahoo Japan Maps (Best viewed on a desktop browser, WordPress resizes the 50% image to 25% on mobile browsers).
There isn’t any meaningful detail in Apple or Google maps at 10%, but you can make out the red Shinjuku station outline and yellow/orange major roads in Yahoo Japan Maps.
The basic information in Yahoo Japan Maps is surprisingly clear even at 25%, Google Maps much less so, Apple Maps not at all.
At 50% the large bold text station labels in Yahoo Japan Maps are coming into focus. Google Maps Japanese text is clean but still too small for my eyes to make out. Google’s use of the similar colors for the map background and Shinjuku station is just wrong. Apple Maps does offer a little more contrast between the background and Shinjuku station, but the low contrast colored text is illegible, and the technicolor measles icon overlay Apple uses is pure distraction that offers zero information.
I have always said that Yahoo Japan Maps has the best cartography of the big three Japanese digital maps. To be fair though Yahoo Japan Maps does have it easy, they only have to focus map resources on Japan and use Bing maps for the rest of the world. Apple and Google have to map the whole world.
(The full size screen shots used in the above comparisons are included below)
That sinking feeling. Here it is mid July already, two, maybe three months until the release of iOS 10. That’s very little time to fix things, if it can be done at all. It reminds me of the iOS 6 beta cycle. I assumed all the Japanese map problems in the WWDC beta would be fixed by the final release. They never were and the rest is history.
I have covered the Apple Maps Japanese label problem in recent posts, here and here. In iOS 9 it isn’t highly visible as the user has to drill down and open the info card before they can see the label. In iOS 10 on a iPad, the info card immediately pops up when a place icon is selected. This is a problem for Japanese public transit service, due to arrive with iOS 10: Apple Maps often mislabels Japanese train stations. Let’s take a look at Shinjuku Station.
The Japanese label listed for Shinjuku Station above, underlined in red, is “Romen-Densha-Eki” which literally translates as “surface electric train station”. The actual meaning is “Street Car Station”. Shinjuku Station has street cars? Of course not. This error is probably due to machine translation that has not been checked by a human being who understands Japanese.
Shinagawa Station is labeled as a “Tetsudo-Eki”, which does translate as “railroad station”. However this usage is old fashioned and nowadays refers to non-electric diesel trains. This might be appropriate for a non-electrified areas like Hokkaido, but not the best choice for a major Tokyo station where all the trains are electrified.
The label for Yuki-ga-otsuka station reads as “Unso”. This literally means “shipping” or “transport”, as in ship cargo or truck cargo. This is a passenger train station so it looks like another machine translation that needs fixing by a human being.
These kind of label errors will not instill user confidence in Japanese public transit if they are not corrected before the rollout this fall. To be fair though, Google Maps doesn’t always get Japanese station lables exactly right every time either.
After comparing Dilger’s take with my own, something didn’t feel right. Digger’s piece focuses on the slow rollout of public transit in Apple Maps and what Apple is doing about it. My take took the cultural curation PR-speak of the WWDC presentation and attempted to show that it was a joke in light of the problems with Apple Maps in Japan, and that Apple’s basic process is flawed.
After reflecting on it I think both takes are limited observations that miss a much larger and deeper set of issues resulting from the decisions Apple made when launching the maps effort in 2010~2011. A lot has been written about Apple Maps since the 2012 debut but there’s not much publicly available hard analysis by industry experts. The best I ever found is Dr. Mike Dobson’s Exploring Local blog.
Failure to recognize the difficulty integrating information from disparate data sources.
General incompetence in rationalizing data sources.
In summary Dobson said:
If you go back over this blog and follow my recounting of the history of Google’s attempts at developing a quality mapping service, you will notice that they initially tried to automate the entire process and failed miserably, as has Apple. Google learned that you cannot take the human out of the equation…The issue plaguing Apple Maps is not mathematics or algorithms, it is data quality.
It’s clear from Dilger’s post and comments by tech bloggers such as John Gruber of Daring Fireball, that Apple Maps services have improved for users in the US and other countries. Apple Maps in Japan is still a 2012 era product however, displaying all the problems laid out by Dobson. Data quality requires human beings, I suspect there are not many Japanese working on Japanese maps. For that reason I predict the Japanese public transit service in iOS 10 will suffer from the same problems, but that is not the whole story.
I have previously noted in this blog my interest in how long Google might be able to sustain its “spend” on mapping software. I think we now have an answer. It is my impression that the heady days of map development at Google are over and that its map products will be maintained at or near their existing levels, but with little innovation, other than in regards to autonomous navigation systems, as we proceed into the future. Google, unfortunately, is approaching middle-age and is developing the concerns that accompany fiscal responsibility…
Although it is early in game for Apple, I doubt they will fare much better. In its favor, the company has been more circumspect about spending. It appears to have out-thought Google’s mapping innovations and found of way to reach near-parity without spending as much as Google. However, in the long run, Apple’s market is limited to its own customer base, and quality mapping will be too expensive to support without some fundamental change in Apple’s business model. I suspect that eventually Apple will find that it, too, cannot afford to support its mapping programs at the desired level of accuracy and functionality.
As the market matures for both Apple and Google, the sustainability of digital map development costs will certainly come under pressure, and with it quality and functionality could suffer.
The iOS 10 preview image for Apple Maps Japanese public transit is fascinating. It’s a coming attraction movie trailer. Movie trailers, as you know, always use background music that has nothing to do with the actual movie and have scenes that are never in the final film. With that in mind, let’s look at some details.
The image shows the Shinjuku station footprint in transit view with surrounding above ground station structures, department stores in this case, in light semi-transparent purple, and the basement structures in pink. The JR and subway lines are marked in different colors as you might expect but the high contrast solid dark purple platform footprints are something entirely new and a welcome change. The current iOS 9 transit view shows platform footprints in typical, cartoony Apple Maps cartography style: light pink on light pink outlines on light beige background that is super low contrast and very hard to see.
Compared with the current iOS 9 cartography, the iOS 10 style transit lines look thinner and a little harder to see. Bold is always better and Apple Maps would be better off not following the Google Maps transit style in which train and subway lines are too thin to stand out against the background.
The JR train line has a new style that is instantly recognizable. It actually looks like a real, black and white dashed train line seen in maps of yore, in Google, or in any other digital map out there. FINALLY.
Local Signage – Circles Out, Squares In?
The preview image shows a lot more local signage. The old style blue generic train station icon is replaced by the official JR logo, but something doesn’t look right. The current iOS 10 beta maps cartography goes all in with round icons, and Apple has been busy over the past few month swapping out Japanese square icon signage with round versions. This looks like a movie trailer scene that will be missing in the final release.
There are lots of important details left to the imagination that will make or break the Japanese public transit service. What will passageways, exits, board instructions and directions all look like? Shinjuku and Tokyo are the largest and most complex stations in the world. It’s such a huge challenge that even Google Maps doesn’t get it right. It will be fascinating to see what Japanese public transit experience Apple delivers in iOS 10 Maps.