French cartoonist view of Japanese, what more do you need to know?
Instead of doing research Justin McCurry called up a few western colleagues for their opinions about Japan. This is not journalism. Consultant Sarah Parsons thanks Justin for all the attention he gave her in the article, very good for her business.
Only now is Reuters picking up the French connection side of the story which has been reported in Japanese media since day one and is a well-known narrative: Seeds of Renault-Nissan crisis sown in Macron’s ‘raid’. When Ghosn came to Japan to fix Nissan he promised that Nissan stay separate and would never be merged with Renault. Macron the “former Rothschild dealmaker” broke that promise:
Then, on the evening of April 7, (2015) Macron called Ghosn to let him know – as a courtesy – that the state had bought another 4.73 percent of Renault for 1.2 billion euros ($1.4 billion), would announce its maneuver in the morning and planned to sell back down to 15 percent only after defeating his (Ghosn’s) opt-out.
With that step, seen by detractors and admirers alike as an unprecedented government “raid”, the simmering battle of egos between Ghosn the global CEO and Macron the wunderkind banker-turned-minister had burst into the open.
Brushing aside warnings, Macron pressed ahead and defeated the opt-out. The vote handed France an effective blocking minority at Renault, which in turn controlled Nissan shareholder meetings via its 43.4 percent stake in the Japanese firm.
Alarm bells rang in Tokyo as that sank in, ratcheting tensions higher over the months that followed.
Macron’s actions to push a Nissan-Renault merger broke all the trust Ghosn had built over the years with Nissan. Ghosn is certainly a victim as the western press likes to portray him but not at the hands of “the Japanese”, but by Macron himself. As the Reuters story makes clear, “President Macron himself has skin in the game,” Ghosn was just a disposable tool and stepping stone to the Élysée Palace.
First YouTube and now Twitter is freezing mainstream conservative commentators. Kazuya’s bogus YouTube purge for ‘spam’ a few days ago, now reinstated after a overwhelming response from online Japanese across the political spectrum, has been followed by Twitter freezing his account. Two attacks this close together is not coincidence. I smell a rat.
The Twitter takedown is particularly bogus: a ‘well known’ lawyer lodged 4 copyright complaints on a Kazuya tweet that URL links to Kazuya’s own YouTube Channel video. In short somebody claimed copyright on content they don’t own. Twitter froze Kazuya’s account anyway. This is somebody hijacking DMCA rules to take down somebody else they don’t want on Twitter. Maybe Twitter wants it that way.
The YouTube purge has already damaged YouTube’s credibility in Japan because they don’t offer real reasons for banning or reinstating Kazuya’s account or other similar conservative commentator YouTuber accounts that are still frozen. YouTube comes across as being completely arbitrary or worse, politically motivated, a huge turn off for many Japanese.
If Twitter doesn’t do a better job of filtering bogus copyright claims and falls into the trap of becoming somebody else’s tool, Twitter credibility in Japan will be destroyed too.
Your choice Twitter.
Now Twitter has been caught engaging in Shadow Banning of conservative Twitter users but changed it overnight when caught by Vice. Meanwhile Kazuya’s Twitter account still remains frozen for unexplained reasons.
The YouTube purge of conservative and right-wing channels as described by Tim Pool earlier this year has hit Japan hard recently with many high-profile and popular channels such as Tsuneyasu Takeda and Kazuya taken down for vague YouTube community violations, spam mostly.
This is not fringe but mainstream commentators who write books, major magazine articles and appear on Japanese TV. Tsuneyasu Takeda is a university professor whose family are descendants from the Meiji Emperor. You cannot get more mainstream than that.
The takedowns are exactly the ‘one strike you’re out purge’ method that Tim Pool describes under the YouTube spam violation policies.
Takeda and Kazuya have both setup new YouTube Channels while their cases and uploaded catalog are ‘reviewed’ but subscriber numbers are way down as you’d expect. Pre-purge Kazuya had 490,000 subscribers, now he has 38,000. If YouTube’s intention here is to disrupt Japanese conservative commentators ahead of Japanese Diet elections due later this year, they certainly achieved that.
Regardless of politics I think YouTube’s purge first review later (if ever) action for dubious reasons is deplorable. This has already thrown a chill on Japanese online communities. Japanese take pride in listening to and respecting opinions of others even if they don’t agree with them. I think a lot of younger Japanese, and bloggers will think twice before trusting YouTube, or Google again.
The Japanese response to YouTube’s purge of the Kazuya Channel was so overwhelming that 3 hours after informing Kazuya that the YouTube review of his channel confirmed that it violated YouTube spam policies, without giving any specifics, and would not be reinstated, he received yet another email stating that the YouTube review found his channel did not violate spam policies and was reinstated. Again without offering any details or explanation. Kazuya thanked his followers in a comeback video but observed that YouTube’s actions may have damaged its reputation in Japan.
The on again off again currency swap deal between the Bank of Japan and the People’s Bank of China is on again for the tune of a curiously small sum of 3 Trillion JPY. Those in the know say that kind of sum is useless for anything more than helping out a company or two, in this case a life raft for Panasonic’s disastrous China market business.