Sometimes there are advantages in being late to a party. JR East Suica and JR West ICOCA are following different regional service expansion strategies with JR West leveraging their late arrival to mobile to innovate in some ways that JR East has chosen not to. They both have the same goal: bring regional rail and bus company ‘feeder’ lines into the Suica and ICOCA service area for easy transfers and ‘win-win’ value capture for the big guys and the small guys.
JR East has the Suica 2 in 1 Region Affiliate card program that I have covered extensively since it was announced in 2018. Suica 2 in 1 is a custom hardware based solution, using the enhanced functionality of the FeliCa SD2 platform to create fully featured Suica cards with region specific features (commuter passes, transit points, senior discounts and other services). The JR East Suica ID and the regional affiliate ID on Suica 2 in 1 cards allows a regional server to host those features while the JR East Suica servers host the regular Suica features (Stored Fare, Suica commuter passes, JRE POINT, etc.). The hardware cost of installing Suica 2 in 1 systems on local transit operations is partially offset by prefectural subsidies.
JR West on the other hand is using lower cost off the shelf hardware, mobile based store readers. This means losing a few things: (1) no automatic fare calculation compared to regular ICOCA systems, the bus driver / train operator manually inputs the fare and the users taps out like regular store payment, (2) no commuter pass support, (3) no regional point system support. JR West assumes (correctly) that regional operators don’t need full spec off-line FeliCa speed, online retail FeliCa will be enough to do the job. work around the limitations, JR West has cleverly opened up their commuter pass system, creating a new ICOCA Web commuter pass service, iCOMPASS that launched in January 2025. iCOMPASS allows up to 5 ICOCA and /or ICOCA region affiliate passes to be attached to a single ICOCA card, either plastic or Mobile ICOCA, linking the ICOCA card number to the ICOMPASS commuter pass server. As for regional points, well there are lots of choices as long as the choice is WESTER POINT.
There is another advantage to being late to mobile: a new system has less legacy baggage, few device profiles, to support. There is also the question of scale. Mobile Suica is huge, both in issue numbers and everyday use. It makes sense for Mobile ICOCA to host the recently announced Mobile TOICA (2026) and Mobile SUGOCA (2027). Even added together they are dwarfed by Suica.
That still leaves the point system problem to address: will Mobile TOICA and Mobile SUGOCA be tethered to WESTER POINT or free to do their own thing? And what about regional operators using ICOCA?
They are tradeoffs to be sure, Suica 2 in 1 has full spec powered Suica everywhere but a higher hardware bar. Regional ICOCA has some limitations but covers the basics at a lower cost. One size doesn’t fit all. Both approaches are valid. It will be fun watching how it all plays out. Transit tech writer Tatsuya Edakubo wrote some great articles covering the details of each approach, machine translations copied below. By all means read the Japanese originals if you can.
**While PASMO Stagnates, ICOCA Rapidly Expands** IC card tickets have become essential for train and bus travel. However, their adoption is primarily concentrated in major cities, and it’s not uncommon to find routes in rural areas without IC card support. Since 2021, small and medium-sized regional railway and bus operators in western Japan have increasingly adopted JR West’s ICOCA card. Recently, Chugoku Bus and Tomo Railway in Hiroshima Prefecture, Kasai Bus Company in Okayama Prefecture, and Meiko Bus in Wakayama Prefecture began accepting ICOCA from March 30 and April 4, respectively. Medium-sized railway operators in regional cities, such as Iyotetsu Group in Ehime Prefecture, Echizen Railway, and Fukui Railway in Fukui Prefecture, also became fully compatible with nationwide transportation IC cards starting in March. As of March this year, over 50 operators have adopted ICOCA. In eastern Japan, however, progress is slower.
While PASMO, jointly introduced by private railway and bus operators in the Kanto region, exists, only a few operators, such as Chichibu Railway, Toyo Bus, Eagle Bus, and Kanetsu Kotsu Service, have adopted it in the past five years. While PASMO’s expansion among smaller operators stagnates, why is JR West’s ICOCA spreading so rapidly? To uncover the reasons, we spoke with Nobuhiro Sakai, section chief of JR West’s Digital Solutions Headquarters WESTER-X Business Division. Japan’s IC card ticket system began with JR East’s Suica in 2001, followed by JR West’s ICOCA in 2003, Kansai’s private operators’ PiTaPa in 2004, JR Central’s TOICA in 2006, and Kanto’s private operators’ PASMO in 2007, covering most urban railways in Tokyo, Nagoya, and Osaka. Subsequently, IC cards emerged in Hokkaido, Kyushu, Tohoku, and Hokuriku, with the “Nationwide IC Card Interoperability Service” launching in 2013 among ten major cards. However, high implementation costs slowed adoption in rural areas.
Simplified IC Terminals Accelerate Adoption
JR West seized this opportunity. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the company formulated the “JR West Group Digital Strategy” in October 2020 and established the Digital Solutions Headquarters in November. This initiated open innovation, integrating railway business transformation (DX) with external solution sales, as frequently covered in this series. A key pillar of this strategy is building the “WESTER World,” linking the J-WEST credit card, mobile ICOCA, and Wesmo! via WESTER points. The first step is expanding ICOCA’s user base. ICOCA’s service area expanded from the Kansai region to suburban areas, and since 2019, JR West introduced low-cost “onboard IC ticket gates” to local lines like the Sakai Line, Wakayama Line, and Nanao Line. In 2021, JR West began selling the ICOCA system to regional railway and bus operators, and the introduction of cost-effective “simplified IC terminals” in 2022 accelerated adoption. While “simplified” refers to the terminals, for convenience, we’ll call the system for regional operators “simplified ICOCA.”JR West’s ICOCA services vary but share the same basic structure. Like Suica, nationwide IC card systems are built around FeliCa cards. Fares are calculated using boarding station (or bus stop) data stored on the card and fare tables in reader-writer terminals, updating the card’s balance. Usage and balance data are sent to a central server via relay servers. Whether standard ticket gates, simplified gates, or onboard gates, the core system remains the same. The high cost of IC card systems stems from investments in FeliCa cards, reader-writer terminals, and servers. So, why can smaller operators adopt simplified ICOCA? Sakai explains it’s customized to regional needs: “For example, in areas with a flat 180-yen fare, complex fare calculations aren’t needed. By trimming unnecessary functions, we reduce data handling.”
JR West’s Solution Sales: Beyond Mere Products
For JR West, with numerous stations, routes, and complex fare systems, building and verifying programs is costly. Smaller operators, however, have simpler needs, fewer users, and different requirements for communication lines, server scale, and terminal specs compared to urban areas. Sakai notes, “Railway reader-writer terminals are designed for rush-hour processing of over 45 people per minute, but in rural areas, such high-speed processing isn’t necessary, so retail-level terminals suffice.” However, JR West doesn’t simply sell simplified ICOCA as a catalog “product.” As detailed in our March 4, 2024, article, “Why JR West’s New Technology Was Adopted at Nippon-Ham’s New Stadium,” JR West’s solution sales are neither pure “reselling” nor consulting. They involve collaborative discussions to identify challenges, propose tailored solutions, and implement them with customization, offering unmatched “problem-solving” and “partnership” strengths. Sakai emphasizes, “We don’t just sell existing systems. It’s about leveraging our solutions to create something together, asking, ‘What can we do?’”This approach stems from JR West’s unique position. While Suica pioneered IC cards, only ICOCA and PASMO were independently developed, with later systems borrowing Suica’s framework. ICOCA and PASMO share compatible specs, ensuring no user-facing differences, but JR West’s experience in building its own system enables greater customization flexibility. Additionally, JR West’s subsidiary, JR West Tecsea, has produced reader-writer terminals via OEM from the start. This expertise led to the ICOCA Web commuter pass service, iCOMPASS, launched in January 2025, which became a game-changer for simplified ICOCA, particularly for bus operators. Facing tight budgets and labor shortages, expanding commuter pass sales counters is challenging. Sakai notes, “iCOMPASS started with solving these pressing issues through online sales, and it resonated strongly.”
JR Central and JR Kyushu “Ride” ICOCA
Tatsuya Edakubo “Well, duh”: JR West’s ICOCA on a Roll While PASMO’s Left in the Dust
Let’s clarify iCOMPASS’s mechanism. Nationwide IC cards can store one bus commuter pass (if the operator supports it), but it requires writing data to the card at a ticket counter or machine. With iCOMPASS, users input their ICOCA card’s unique ID on a dedicated site during purchase. When tapped, the terminal checks the card’s ID against the central server to verify the pass, enabling fully online transactions. While standard ICOCA supports one pass, iCOMPASS allows up to five passes to be linked to a single card. JR West’s “ICOCA export” is entering a new phase. On March 7, JR Central announced it would launch “mobile TOICA” in spring 2026, and JR Kyushu will introduce “mobile SUGOCA” in spring 2027, both built on mobile ICOCA’s system. The author was surprised that JR Central and JR Kyushu “rode” ICOCA, but Sakai explains, “Being connected by rail creates a natural foundation for collaboration. Working together enables efficient system operations and faster initiatives.” Mobile TOICA and mobile SUGOCA, built on mobile ICOCA, are treated as ICOCA under payment laws. Issuing commuter passes under the ICOCA name could be confusing, so they’re developed as standalone apps. Sakai notes there’s room for customization, with potential for unique features in the future.
Suica to Enable Cross-Area Use by Spring 2027
JR East has announced the “Suica Renaissance,” a plan to progressively upgrade Suica’s functions over the next decade. The core of this initiative is transitioning from a system where data is managed on IC cards to one where a central server processes and records data. Currently, the Suica system operates in six areas: the Tokyo metropolitan area, Sendai, Niigata, and three regions in Tohoku (Morioka, Aomori, and Akita). However, cross-area use is not possible due to the limited memory capacity of IC cards and ticket gates for fare calculations. To address this, JR East plans to enable cross-area Suica use, such as traveling from Ueno to Sendai, by spring 2027. In the future, leveraging features like location tracking in the Suica app, the goal is to make Suica usable across all lines and stations.However, JR East is not the only operator in eastern Japan. In the Tokyo area, Suica is interoperable with PASMO, used by private railways and buses. Extending Suica’s usability to local private railways and buses is essential to realize a society where one card enables seamless travel. A May 5 article highlighted that regional railways and bus operators in western Japan are increasingly adopting JR West’s simplified ICOCA system. So, how is JR East approaching regional expansion? Based on interviews with JR East’s Marketing Headquarters Suica and Payment Systems Department, we explore the latest developments.
Challenges in Standardizing Services with Regional Cards
Local IC cards predate Suica, with examples like Skyrail (discontinued in 2024), Donan Bus, and Yamanashi Kotsu adopting FeliCa-based services in the late 1990s, alongside other standards. Since Suica’s launch in 2001, systems based on Suica, such as ICOCA and PASMO, have spread, culminating in the 2011 introduction of Nagoya’s manaca, completing IC card adoption in major urban areas. In March 2013, nationwide interoperability was achieved among ten transportation IC cards, including Suica and PASMO. However, in rural areas, while some operators like Ainokaze Toyama Railway adopted ICOCA, others, such as Kotohira Electric Railway’s IruCa, Fukushima Kotsu’s NORUCA, and Okayama Electric Tramway’s Hareca, introduced region-specific cards to meet local needs, creating challenges for standardization.The ten interoperable cards connect through their servers and an IC card interoperability center, enabling use across all regions. Connecting all local (Suica-standard) IC card systems similarly is feasible but costly, making it burdensome for smaller regional operators.Since 2011, some regions have adopted “one-way interoperability.” For example, Niigata Kotsu’s ryuto card uses a relay server alongside its ID management server to connect to the interoperability center via Suica, allowing the ten cards to be used in ryuto areas. However, ryuto cannot be used in the ten-card areas due to unconnected data, prioritizing convenience for business and tourist visitors from urban areas. This approach, however, requires additional relay server costs and is limited to a few operators like Sendai’s icsca and Sapporo’s SAPICA.
Overcoming Cost Barriers with Technological Advancements
In March 2015, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism established a committee to promote IC card adoption and convenience, emphasizing inbound tourism. As foreign visitors increasingly expect a single IC card to suffice, the committee proposed filling gaps through new card adoption or one-way interoperability with regional cards.While the proposed “one-way interoperability system” was not realized, standardizing regional cards became unavoidable. Regions introducing new cards or updating existing ones (every ~7 years) must now address system integration.In September 2018, JR East announced the development of “regional collaboration IC cards,” enabling regional services like bus passes alongside Suica’s ticketing and e-money functions on a single card. These cards eliminate the need for regional ID or relay servers by operating within the Suica system. Branded as AOPASS, AkiCA, iGUCA, etc., with unique designs, they carry JR East’s “JE” ID, functioning fully as Suica cards, including Shinkansen use and JRE POINT registration, enhancing convenience across the ten-card areas.The cards use an extended FeliCa OS, partitioning memory to create a “2-in-1 card” that supports regional services. Operators pay system usage fees to access Suica’s regional servers, sharing development and operational costs to provide affordable, high-quality IC card systems. A JR East representative emphasized, “In transportation, being a ‘sneaky outlier’ doesn’t work. You must be a ‘connector’ saying, ‘join us.’”Starting with totra in March 2021, 15 regional cards, including KURURU in March 2025, have been introduced, with plans for further expansion. In December 2024, Nozawa Onsen Kotsu, a small bus operator, adopted the ten cards via regional servers without issuing its own card, catering to Tokyo tourists. This demonstrates a cost-effective realization of one-way interoperability.
Tatsuya Edakubo “Whoa, Suica is here too?!” Spilling the beans on JR East’s Epic Plot for the Ultimate “Regional Affiliate IC Card”
You must be logged in to post a comment.